How to Choose Your First Legacy Game (Without Regretting It)

How to Choose Your First Legacy Game (Without Regretting It)

How to Choose Your First Legacy Game (Without Regretting It)

Legacy games—titles that evolve with each session, permanently altering components, unlocking content, and creating a unique campaign—offer unmatched immersion. But the commitment can be daunting: missing an envelope reveal or spending $60+ on a game you don’t enjoy can sting. Here’s how to pick your first legacy experience wisely.

1. Understand the Commitment

  • Game Length & Campaign Arc
    Legacy campaigns run 6–12 sessions (e.g., Pandemic Legacy Season 1 is 12 games; Charterstone is 12 rounds). Plan dates in advance so you don’t lose momentum.

  • Component Permanence
    Stickers, stamps, and opened envelopes change the game forever. If you’re prone to attachment issues or shifting group availability, consider a “legacy-lite” (e.g., Charterstone has stickers but can reset).

2. Group Size and Dynamics

  • Best for Couples or Small Groups
    2–4 players is typical. Games with soloplay options (e.g., Imperial Assault: Legends) or 5-player variance (e.g., some expansions) suit different circles.

  • Player Availability
    Legacy requires consistent players. If your friends vanish mid-campaign, you’ll scramble to finish. Opt for a game with fewer mandatory envelopes or a campaign you can pause.

3. Replayability & Reset Options

  • Solo and Campaign Modes
    Some legacy titles (like Aeon’s End Legacy) include solo campaigns or rules for post-campaign replay. Check if a game offers a “post-legacy mode” so the box doesn’t gather dust after opening.

  • Legacy-Lite vs. Full Legacy

    • Legacy-Lite: Limited permanent changes (stickers, minor card removals). Charterstone, Fugitive Legacy

    • Full Legacy: Extensive envelope reveals, permanent component loss. Pandemic Legacy, Gloomhaven

4. Theme & Flavor

  • Player Interests

    • Co-op thrill: Pandemic Legacy Season 1/2

    • Story-driven exploration: Gloomhaven, T.I.M.E Stories

    • Light narrative with puzzles: The King's Dilemma
      Choose a theme that fits your group’s tastes—medical crisis vs. fantasy dungeon crawl vs. narrative mystery.

5. Budget & Availability

  • Upfront Cost
    Legacy games often start at $60 and go up to $140 (e.g., Gloomhaven). Factor in expansions or reshipping replacements if you lose components.

  • Secondary Market
    Popular titles can skyrocket used prices. If resale is a priority, look for legacy-lite or limited runs (some sealed copies hold collector value).

6. Top Beginner-Friendly Legacy Games

Title Sessions Players Why It’s Beginner-Friendly
Pandemic Legacy: Season 1 12 2–4 Clear mission structure, well-paced difficulty curve.
Charterstone 12 1–6 Legacy-lite resettable campaign; building village theme.
Aeon’s End Legacy 10 1–4 Solo-ready, deckbuilding; minimal permanent changes.
T.I.M.E Stories 10–15 2–4 Narrative-driven scenario decks; replayable with new modules.
Mice & Mystics 15 1–4 Storybook narrative; minimal permanent alterations.

Final Tips

  • Watch a Playthrough: YouTube series can reveal game flow and component changes.

  • Join Online Communities: Reddit and BoardGameGeek forums for spoilers-free advice.

  • Schedule Ahead: Block game nights in your calendar to complete the campaign.

Enjoy the thrill of watching your game world transform—choose wisely, and your first legacy title will be one you cherish!

Back to blog