Crowdfund or Wait for Retail? Pros and Cons for Shoppers

Crowdfund or Wait for Retail? Pros and Cons for Shoppers

Crowdfund or Wait for Retail? Pros and Cons for Shoppers

Deciding whether to back a board game on Kickstarter or wait for its retail launch can feel like a gamble. This guide will help you weigh the benefits and drawbacks so you can choose the path that aligns with your budget, appetite for risk, and desire for exclusive content.

Why Consider Crowdfunding?

Pros

  1. Early Access & Exclusive Rewards

    • Often month(s) before retail release

    • Access to Kickstarter-exclusive stretch goals (promo cards, deluxe components, minis)

  2. Community Engagement

    • Follow development updates and provide feedback

    • Connect with fellow backers in campaign forums

  3. Potential Savings

    • Early-bird discounts and bundle tiers can lower cost per game

  4. Support Indie Creators

    • Directly fund small designers and innovative concepts

Cons

  1. Long Wait & Uncertainty

    • Typical fulfillment 6–18 months after campaign ends

    • Risk of delays, production issues, or cancellation

  2. Shipping & Customs

    • International shipping fees can be steep

    • Possible customs duties upon arrival

  3. Uncertain Final Quality

    • Prototype vs. mass-produced components may differ

    • Limited feedback before mass printing

  4. No Returns

    • Digital pledge agreements usually can’t be canceled once funded

Why Wait for Retail?

Pros

  1. Immediate Availability

    • Pick up from local game stores or online retailers

    • No waiting period once released

  2. Transparent Reviews & Ratings

    • Consult BoardGameGeek ratings and unboxing videos

    • Online retailer reviews highlight component quality and rule clarity

  3. Standardized Pricing

    • Avoid unexpected shipping surcharges

    • Easier price comparisons across sellers

  4. Return & Warranty Options

    • Some retailers accept returns or exchanges

    • Manufacturer customer service for defects

Cons

  1. Potentially Higher Cost

    • MSRP often excludes Kickstarter’s early-bird discounts

  2. Missed Exclusives

    • Retail versions may omit Kickstarter-only cards or deluxe minis

  3. Stock Issues

    • Popular titles can sell out quickly; may require pre-order

    • Secondary market markups on out-of-stock games

Decision Matrix: Which Path Fits You?

Factor Crowdfund Retail
Budget Flexible tiers, potential savings Standard MSRP
Risk Tolerance High (delays, no returns) Low (instant purchase, returns)
Desire for Exclusives Very high (stretch goals) Low–none
Need Fast Delivery No Yes
Quality Assurance Prototype unknown Proven production quality

Tips for a Smooth Crowdfunding Experience

  1. Research Creator Track Record: Review past campaign fulfillment histories.

  2. Check Shipping Estimates: Factor in both pledge and delivery costs.

  3. Follow Campaign Comments: Keep an eye on production updates and backer feedback.

  4. Budget for Add-Ons: Decide in advance which stretch goals matter most to you.

Tips for Smart Retail Purchases

  1. Pre-Order Strategically: Sign up for local store notifications.

  2. Bundle Deals: Watch for retailer promos (holiday bundles, bundle with expansions).

  3. Wait for Sales: Black Friday and holiday discounts often include major titles.

  4. Inspect on Arrival: Check for missing/damaged components promptly.

Back to blog